NAIA All-Americans
NAIA All-Americans
2021-22
| Name | Sport |
| Jace Capps | Football |
| Tyler Watson | Men's Soccer |
| Marie Bathe | Women's Soccer |
| Carter Cox | Wrestling |
| Anthony Maia | Wrestling |
| Keshawn Laws | Wrestling |
| Cole Smith | Wrestling |
| Tavon King | Men's Basketball |
| Tyra Johnson | Women's Basketball |
| Praise Idamadudu | Women's Indoor Track & Field (200m) |
| Praise Idamadudu | Women's Indoor Track & Field (400m) |
| Sibanda Dumoluhle | Men's Indoor Track & Field (Triple Jump) |
| Georget Pontillo | Men's Indoor Track & Field (800m) |
| Emma Hermansson | Women's Golf |
| Nathalie Nutu | Women's Golf |
| Daveina Watson | Women's Outdoor Track & Field (Shot Put) |
| Praise Idamadudu | Women's Outdoor Track & Field (200m) |
| Praise Idamadudu | Women's Outdoor Track & Field (400m) |
| Sibanda Dumoluhle | Men's Outdoor Track & Field (Triple Jump) |
| Jaylen Poole | Men's Outdoor Tack & Field (Triple Jump) |
| Georget Pontillo | Men's Outdoor Track & Field (800m) |
| Tobi Oniyide | Men's Outdoor Track & Field (100m) |
| Nolan Machibroda | Baseball |
| Jessica Hernandez | Women's Tennis |
2020-21
| Name | Sport |
| Carter Cox | Wrestling |
| Esco Walker | Wrestling |
| Anthony Maia | Wrestling |
| Cole Smith | Wrestling |
| Patrick Depiazza | Wrestling |
| Georget Pontillo | Men's Indoor Track & Field (800m) |
| Treylon Sheppard | Football |
| Bakary Bagayoko | Men's Soccer |
| Sarah Haddock | Women's Soccer |
| Sasha Petrova | Women's Outdoor Track and Field (Marathon) |
| Georget Pontillo | Men's Outdoor Track and Field (800m) |
| Jaylen Poole | Men's Outdoor Track and Field (Triple Jump) |
| Isaac Walker | Men's Golf |
2019-20
| Name | Sport |
| Marie Bathe | Women's Soccer |
| Jalen Duke | Men's Basketball |
| Bumnene Ndebele | Men's Indoor Track & Field (Triple Jump) |
| Tyler Williams | Men's Indoor Track & Field (60 Meter Dash) |
| Tyler Williams | Men's Indoor Track & Field (200 Meter Dash) |
| Nathan Walton | Wrestling |
| Patrick Depiazza | Wrestling |
| Maria Bangala | Women's Indoor Track & Field (400 Meter Dash) |
| Kanellar Carney | Women's Indoor Track & Field (60 Meter Hurdles) |
| Kanellar Carney | Women's Track & Field (High Jump) |
2018-19
| Name | Sport |
| Ramon Puertolas | Men's Tennis |
| Francisco Fernandez-Meaca | Men's Tennis |
| Anthony Maia | Wrestling |
| Nathan Walton | Wrestling |
| Ana Laura Pages Preuss | Women's Golf |
| Raquel Romero Valverde | Women's Golf |
| Rebecca Holloway | Women's Soccer |
| Sarah Haddock | Women's Soccer |
| Tyra Graham | Softball |
| Bumnene Ndebele | Men's Track & Field (Triple Jump) |
| Charles Shimukowa | Men's Track & Field (800 Meter) |
| Charles Shimukowa | Men's Track & Field (800 Meter) |
2017-18
| Name | Sport |
| Rayden Sierra | Baseball |
| Diondrey Holt Jr. | Men's Basketball |
| Brian McNamara | Men's Soccer |
| Tyler Watson | Men's Soccer |
| Ramon Puertolas | Men's Tennis |
| Pau Grabuleda Cruañas | Men's Tennis |
| Mariah Aplin | Women's Soccer |
| Rebecca Holloway | Women's Soccer |
| Kaitlen Kisiloski | Women's Soccer |
| Ainhoa Garijo Garrido | Women's Tennis |
| Marianela Landi | Women's Tennis |
2016-17
| Name | Sport |
| Austin Kranjak | Baseball |
| Diondrey Holt Jr | Men's Basketball |
| Sammy Rosario | Wrestling |
| Nate Croley | Wrestling |
| Kyle Delaune | Wrestling |
| Nicole Bowers | Women's Basketball |
| Emily Shires | Women's Soccer |
| Rebecca Holloway | Women's Soccer |
2015-16
| Name | Sport |
| Sondre Risa | Men's Soccer |
| Chelsey Hall | Women's Basketball |
| Olivia Chu | Women's Soccer |
| Angelica Sepulveda | Women's Tennis |
2014-15
| Name | Sport |
| Scott Stewart | Wrestling |
| Kyle Delaune | Wrestling |
| Jake Williams | Wrestling |
| Chelsey Hall | Women's Basketball |
| Lindsay Kitson | Women's Soccer |
| Shauna Gipson | Women's Soccer |
| Renee LaRose | Women's Soccer |
| Kaitlin Phillips | Women's Soccer |
| Angelica Sepulveda | Women's Tennis |
2013-14
| Name | Sport |
| Sam Lind | Baseball |
| Ricky Coleman | Baseball |
| Antonio Manuel Marcelo | Men's Tennis |
| Pablo Borrero | Men's Tennis |
| Austin Garrett | Men's Golf |
| Olivia Chu | Women's Soccer |
| Lindsay Kitson | Women's Soccer |
| Rhianna Parsons | Women's Soccer |
| Shauna Gilpin | Women's Soccer |
| Taylor Nay | Women's Soccer |
| Michelle Ward | Women's Soccer |
| Jessica Roper | Women's Softball |
| Cody Linton | Wrestling |
| Zeke Hunt | Wrestling |
| Jake Williams | Wrestling |
2012-13
| Name | Sport |
| Antonio Manuel Marcelo | Men's Tennis |
| Pedro Rodrigues | Men's Tennis |
| Cody Linton | Wrestling |
| Zeke Hunt | Wrestling |
| Jake Williams | Wrestling |
| Jessica Pace | Women's Basketball |
| Lindsay Kitson | Women's Soccer |
| Kelsey Langille | Women's Soccer |
| Angelica Sepulveda | Women's Tennis |
2011-12
| Name | Sport |
| Mike Mandarino | Baseball |
| Michael Sweat | Men's Basketball |
| Jake Williams | Wrestling |
| Cassie Cowan | Women's Basketball |
2010-11
| Name | Sport |
| Aaron Wilkerson | Baseball |
| Mike Mandarino | Baseball |
| Will Locante | Baseball |
| James Casadaban | Wrestling |
| Corey Bleaken | Wrestling |
2009-10
| Name | Sport |
| Brandon Springer | Men's Basketball |
| Matt Greener | Baseball |
| Troy Frazier | Baseball |
| Kris Miller | Baseball |
| Shawn Schaefer | Baseball |
| Aaron Wilkerson | Baseball |
| James Casadaban | Wrestling |
| Mikey Davis | Wrestling |
2008-09
| Name | Sport |
| Brandon Springer | Men's Basketball |
| Corey Bleaken | Wrestling |
2007-08
| Name | Sport |
| Jordan Power | Wrestling |
| Natasha Yakimovich | Women's Tennis |
| Bea Mompo-Rebaque | Women's Tennis |
2006-07
| Name | Sport |
| Robert Clayton | Baseball |
| Eric Mull | Baseball |
| Corey Bleaken | Wrestling |
| Theo Dotson | Wrestling |
2005-06
| Name | Sport |
| Angel Mercado | Baseball |
| Drew Shetrone | Baseball |
| Victor Alvarez | Baseball |
| Nolan McCue | Baseball |
| Johnathan Laster | Football |
| Tyler McChurch | Football |
2004-05
| Name | Sport |
| Donnie Burkhalter | Baseball |
| Phillip Cuadrado | Baseball |
| Chris Torres | Baseball |
| Derek Depew | Baseball |
| Steve Kline | Baseball |
| Leroy Hickerson | Men's Basketball |
| Keith Cupp | Wrestling |
| Casey Brewster | Wrestling |
2003-04
| Name | Sport |
| Chuck MacFarlane | Baseball |
| Alonzo Evans | Men's Basketball |
| Stephen Westbeld | Wrestling |
2002-03
| Name | Sport |
| Tavaris Gary | Baseball |
| Chili Miranda | Baseball |
| Shaun Child | Baseball |
| Eddie Ortega | Baseball |
| Rob Webbink | Men's Tennis |
| Kate Gerrad | Women's Soccer |
| Natasha Watts | Women's Tennis |
2001-02
| Name | Sport |
| Travis Holland | Baseball |
| Tirzon Nunez | Baseball |
| Matt Hutto | Football |
| John Young | Wrestling |
2000-01
| Name | Sport |
| Dave Beck | Baseball |
| Chris Smith | Baseball |
| Paul Rottman | Baseball |
| Pichi Balet | Baseball |
| Phoeron Scott | Men's Basketball |
| Jessica Jones | Women's Basketball |
1999-00
| Name | Sport |
| Billy Keppinger | Baseball |
| Chad Phillips | Men's Tennis |
| Chatica Hathaway | Women's Basketball |
1998-99
| Name | Sport |
| Eric Hatzell | Baseball |
| Sandy Roga | Baseball |
| Chatica Hathaway | Women's Basketball |
| Delana Burleson | Women's Volleyball |
1997-98
| Name | Sport |
| Randy Stegall | Baseball |
| Brian Foster | Baseball |
| Moises Mandelbaum | Baseball |
| Heath Springer | Football |
| Lisa Holloran | Women's Volleyball |
1996-97
| Name | Sport |
| Mike Dutton | Baseball |
| Steve Green | Baseball |
| Marc Suarez | Baseball |
| Collins Peaden | Football |
1995-96
| Name | Sport |
| Kevin Hite | Baseball |
| Steve Green | Baseball |
| Ray Nawrocki | Baseball |
| Anthony Crawford | Baseball |
| Collins Peaden | Football |
1994-95
| Name | Sport |
| Ric Balius | Baseball |
| Steve Green | Baseball |
| Jason Weilert | Baseball |
| Doug Binkley | Football |
1993-94
| Name | Sport |
| Joe Fushey | Baseball |
| John Kehoe | Baseball |
1992-93
| Name | Sport |
| Pat Sanders | Baseball |
| Dan France | Baseball |
| Scott Corman | Baseball |
1990-91
| Name | Sport |
| Tim Hall | Baseball |
| Bobby Perna | Baseball |
| Luis Ruiz | Baseball |
| Gary Dayhoff | Baseball |
1989-90
| Name | Sport |
| Tim Hall | Baseball |
| Bobby Perna | Baseball |
| Luis Ruiz | Baseball |
| Gary Dayhoff | Baseball |
1988-89
| Name | Sport |
| Gary Dayhoff | Baseball |
1985-86
| Name | Sport |
| Mickey Martin | Baseball |
| Joe Modica | Baseball |
